« I Heart Larry Campbell | Main | Lawyer Investigated for Impaired Driving Charge »

CSI Effect?

Some major recent acquittals: here in Canada, the Air India case. And in the U.S. the celebrity murder, the Robert Blake case.

One hypothesis is the CSI effect. Are juries across the country demanding the sort of high tech evidence we see on TV?

As someone who has had a couple of opportunities to report crimes to the police, I was always amazed at the low-techness of it all. CSI be damned, it's not even like Law & Order! On one occasion, I was told once by a telephone operator when I insisted that the the phone company must have a way to find out who had been crank-calling me "Don't believe everything you see on TV!"

I realise it seems kind of quaint that I kept a Q-tip with saliva of a man who spat on my car, but at the time I really believed they would want that sort of thing to prove who he was. The cop very kindly didn't laugh, but did tell me: "We don't even do that when they steal cars, let alone spit on them."

But the Air India case wasn't a jury trial, it was a judge trial. Could the same issues be at play there? Does the CSI effect affect judges? Or was it simply a matter of not enough evidence?

(N.B. I was surfing Althouse when I found this article.)

Comments

Dude,
That's hilarious that you kept a q-tip of the dude's saliva. You are a huge nerd. I can't believe that you never told me that! In any case, I don't think that civilians are allowed to collect evidence. You could have lifted the saliva off a cigarette or coffee cup and planted it on your car to frame him. I see stuff like that a minimum of 2x per day through my careful analysis of crime scenes and the help of my friends at CSI Las Vegas! YOu could be headed straight for the slammer dahling.......

Post a comment

Want to comment? If you are signed into TypeKey, you'll see a form below. No form? Click on the sign-in link below, and you can sign-in or sign-up for a free account. Sorry you have to use TypeKey, but I use it to avoid comment spam. All comments currently appear automatically after posting.